plot explanation - Who convinced Sansa that he was guilty? - Movies & TV Stack Exchange
Ok, fast forward to the period when Sansa has now fled King's Landing and her abusive relationship with Joffrey. Thanks to Littlefinger's help, she has now taken . As Sansa walked around Winterfell telling various subordinates how they could be doing their jobs better, Littlefinger took her aside and offered. Petyr Baelish's creepy attraction towards Sansa is derived from his teenage hot long term intimate relationships. most likely he views “love” as a weakness.
For book readers, it was a scene we knew could happen, and were bracing ourselves for.
For Unsullied, it was a punch in the gut. But not everyone was okay with yet another rape of yet another leading lady in the ever bleaker world of Game of Thrones. For some, it was the last straw. This is not the first time viewers have threatened to boycott Game of Thrones.
16 Sansa Stark Quotes That Deserve a Round of Applause
In Season 1, it was the death of Ned Stark. In Season 3, it was the Red Wedding. But those threats to quit were different. But most of those reactions came from fans and commenters—the internet hoi-paloi, if you will. I spent a lot of time yesterday, both on and offline, discussing this scene with fans, and have identified three issues. Lastly, people feel it was unnecessary for the show to go there.
I understand that I am in a serious minority when I say that the possibility of this scene has been on my radar since December of last year. After all, we know from previous seasons that the producers tend to show torture scenes onscreen that Martin left off-page.
Perhaps this scene was a surprise for the casual viewer, but the clues were there for anyone who wanted to look. In fact, the reason most of her subsequent abuse does not happen on the page is because Theon is not around to witness it.
Now, the show is not bound by POV characters, and unlike with Jeyne, it spares Sansa from being sexually assaulted by both Theon and Ramsay. As one friend said to me: He has a sharp tongue at times, especially when dealing with Ned Stark in A Game of Thronesbut he knows when to sheathe that tongue, and his real talent lies in his ability to win influence and power, without ever exposing himself to mortal danger.
Every risk he takes is calculated, and though the simple reality of a lowborn lord trying to win the game of thrones comes with inherent danger, he knows how to protect himself within his ambition. The same cannot be said of the corresponding character in the TV shows.
Sansa Stark - A Wiki of Ice and Fire
On HBO, Baelish is by turns peevish, impulsive to the point of recklessnessand transparent. Sansa confronted Littlefinger over his heartless sale of her to Ramsay Bolton, just about the most evil character in Westeros this side of Joffrey.
Martin put on the page. Littlefinger never sent Sansa to marry Ramsay in the books. At the end of A Dance With Dragons, Jeyne Poole, beaten, raped repeatedly, undoubtedly scarred for life in every possible way, is on the run with Theon.
He rightly knows that even though the Stark family is decimated and scattered across two continents, the name still commands the most respect out of any in the North. As we know, things have progressed very differently on HBO. In marrying the actual Sansa to Ramsay, he both gave the Bolton Bastard a legitimate claim to Winterfell and squandered whatever influence he had over Sansa. Now, she hates her one-time savior, to the point that she nearly refused his help in retaking Winterfell—which would have denied him even a meager slice of that pie.
His only saving grace, as usual in the show, was luck. At one point, he even bought off a lord of the Vale to threaten him with violence in the most extreme way possible, forcing a counter-reaction from his enemies and buying him time and influence. Dude makes a winking reference to her incestual relationship with Jaime.
How stupid can you be? What does Baelish possibly have to gain from saying something so incendiary to Cersei Lannister? Absolutely nothing, except the near-death experience that comes to him.
What Baelish does in this scene is rash and reactive, and makes him look sneaky and untrustworthy, which is the exact opposite of his nature as depicted by Martin.
For book loyalists, this departure from character was perhaps the most intellectually offensive scene in the entire series. Petyr is an expert at playing Cersei, and to see him at her mercy is a total betrayal of character. And he makes another incest joke!Sansa & Petyr [She was Lolita]
None of this, needless to say, happens in the books. Which brings us to the worst perversion of Littlefinger brought on by the show: He loved Catelyn Tully with all his heart.